Best Air Hockey Pucks and Paddles: In-Depth Guide and Product Recommendations for 2019

Modern air hockey

If you play air hockey whenever you get the chance, then you know that aside from the table and its blower system, the quality of your mallets and pucks can make all the difference in how you play.

Bringing home the best air hockey table, whether it’s the best round air hockey table or a traditional sized table, can be a great investment for your home or business and can provide endless hours of entertainment. But if you’re an air hockey buff, then you may want to upgrade your accessories and use the best air hockey pucks and paddles for your setup. This puck and mallet guide will go over the leading sets, while discussing which type is right for you, based on air hockey table dimensions, your playing style, and your setup.

I’ve checked out several mallet and puck sets and reviewed the seven top-selling sets on the market. If you don’t want to use the included stock pucks and strikers, then below you’ll find some of the leading sets that can totally change how you play the game, due to their tough design and improved gliding action.

Below, you’ll find a comparison chart for the top seven puck and mallet sets that will show you how many pucks and mallets come per set and how they rated in terms of smoothness, design, action, and overall comfort.

Pucks And Paddles Comparison Table

ProductPucksMallet countMaterialRating
Hathaway Pro-Series Air Hockey Set
Hathaway set Check Price!
22ABS plastic
Dynamo Air Hockey Goalie Mallet Set
Dynamo set Check Price!
NA2ABS plastic
Suzo Happ-Commercial Hockey Set
Suzo happ set Check Price!
22plastic
Qtimal Air Hockey Paddles
Qtimal set Check Price!
42ABS plastic
Billiard Evolution 2 Air Hockey Pushers
Billiard evolution set Check Price!
42ABS plastic
Vktech 4Pcs Air Hockey Goalies
Vktech 4pcs set Check Price!
44plastic
ONE250 Air Hockey Pushers
One250 set Check Price!
44ABS plastic

Best Overall-Hathaway Pro-Series Air Hockey Striker and Puck Set

Hathaway set

Our Rating: (5/5)

If you and your buddies are known for your intense air hockey tournaments on the weekend, then you’re probably searching for strikers and pucks that aren’t going to crack or chip when they’re hit hard and often. While lower-quality accessories are fine if it’s for the best air hockey table for kids, adults need mallets and pucks that can really handle a beating.

Fortunately, Hathaway has provided the perfect solution with a set that’s made out of tougher stuff than the competition, and all for a price that’s affordable.

Additionally, this set comes with an impressive six-month limited warranty, which covers product defects.

This set includes two four-inch strikers, and two three-inch pucks, which makes these pieces perfect for use on a standard-sized air hockey table. The mallets feature an ergonomic design which will promote comfort and longer use. The design will also give you more control over the striker when you play. They’re also slightly heavier, which allows you to use less effort to shoot the puck across the table’s surface. The bottom of the strikers are covered in a thin green felt, for smoother, faster action.

Both the mallets and pucks are made out of ABS plastic, which is crack and chip-resistant, so you won’t have to worry about damaging them during intense gameplay. The material is actually impact resistant and has a reputation for structural stiffness and strength, so you know the pucks and mallets are designed to handle serious wear and tear.

Pros

  • Made out of ABS plastic
  • 180 day limited warranty
  • Ergonomically designed mallets
  • Green felt covered bottoms for smoother gameplay
  • Low price
  • Designed for full-sized tables

Cons

  • Pucks are too thick for smaller-sized tables and can get stuck in the goals.

Conclusion

This package comes with one set of strikers and two pucks. The weight and dimensions of these accessories make them suitable for use on arcade-sized tables. The fact that they’re made out of ABS plastic will be a huge selling point for buyers who are in search of accessories that can handle intense gameplay. Additionally, the mallet’s ergonomic design makes them more comfortable to use and hold, which equals longer gameplay. Overall, this set will be a huge upgrade over the stock accessories that come with your new table. Their limited six-month warranty will also give air hockey table owners every reason to buy.

Best Striker Set-Dynamo Air Hockey Goalie Mallet Set

Dynamo set

Our Rating: (5/5)

If you have a Dynamo air hockey table, or you’re just familiar with the brand and the type of quality they’re known for, then you already know these mallets are really the best that money can buy. Described as the Cadillac of strikers, this set of two by Dynamo is designed for full-sized tables and features the perfect design, weight, and dimensions that can take your gameplay to the next level. While most manufacturers claim that their air hockey accessories are perfect for arcade-style table use, most of them are wrong, or their mallet design consists of hallow, tough plastic that’s difficult to hold onto. But these mallets offer a whole new take on traditional design. They’re durable, powerful, and the perfect weight.

In terms of design, they’re much bigger than stock strikers, they’re also much heavier than a standard mallet.

These mallets are actually designed for competitions and commercial use, so they can be used for tables in the home, or a business, or if you’re part of an air hockey league, then these regulation-sized mallets are a perfect option.

Pros

  • Built tough
  • Durable
  • Glide well
  • Low price

Cons

  • May be too heavy for children

Conclusion

If you’re looking for competition-worthy mallets, your search is over. These strikers will be a great upgrade if you’re tired of using lower-priced or stock mallets that tend to chip or crack in a matter of weeks. Since these strikers are molded as a solid, single unit, they’re much stronger than many styles of strikers that you’ll find on the market. The solid design means you also won’t have to worry about cracks in the design. Basically, you’ll be hard-pressed to find paddles that are more durable. However, considering they’re much heavier than stock strikers, I wouldn’t recommend them for use if you’re buying them specifically for a child’s air hockey table. Due to their bigger size and weight, they’re a much better option for a full-sized table that measures in at seven to eight feet. Overall, these mallets are a great choice and probably the last strikers you’ll ever have to buy. That’s just how tough they are.

Top Set for Commercial Use-Suzo Happ-Commercial Hockey Fluorescent White Goalies

Suzo happ set

Our Rating: (4.5/5)

If you’re looking for an affordable, durable set of paddles and pucks, this set by Suzo Happ is a great option, especially if you’re looking for a tough set that can survive the kids. The lightweight pucks measure in at just a little under three and a half inches and weigh in at just one ounce. Their neon green coloring makes them highly visible during gameplay. The puck’s construction is also designed to improve stability, so you won’t have to worry about it flying off the table during fast gameplay. The large white mallets are comfortable to hold, even for children.

Essentially, while the set isn’t competition worthy since the mallets are very light and smaller than the standard competition strikers, this set will work well for standard-sized tables, round tables, and smaller tables designed for kids.

Both the strikers and the pucks will glow under black light, so you can enjoy a fun, intense game of air hockey in low light conditions.

One of the biggest drawbacks for this set is the fact that the paddles do not have the standard felt covering on the bottom, which means they can potentially damage the surface of the table and may not offer the type of faster gliding action that you’d get with mallets that do have felt covered bottoms.

Pros

  • Lightweight design
  • Mallets and pucks glow in the dark
  • Reasonably priced
  • Perfect for smaller and standard-sized tables

Cons

  • Strikers do not have felt on the bottom

Conclusion

This mallet and puck set will make a great upgrade over stock sets. The white mallets and neon green pucks will glow under black lights, which can add a whole new level of fun. The lightweight design of the mallets makes them suitable for children, however, they’re large enough for adults to easily grip. However, the strikers are somewhat smaller than what you may be used to using on a standard arcade-sized table. The lack of felt covering on the bottom of the mallets can potentially impact gliding action and can put your table at risk of scratches and other cosmetic damage. Yet, the manufacturer claims that the bottoms, despite the lack of felt feature an ultra-slick surface which makes them perfectly safe for use and shouldn’t impact gameplay speed. Overall, while this set isn’t tournament regulation, it’s definitely a big step up from your standard stock striker and puck sets.

Most Versatile-Qtimal Home Standard Air Hockey Paddles and 2 Size Pucks

Qtimal set

Our Rating: (4.5/5)

Qtimal is a giant in the air hockey industry. They’re known for their extensive line of accessories that offer something for everyone, whether you’re looking for the right pucks and strikers for a round or tabletop setup, or you want to make some serious upgrades for your arcade-style table.

If you’re looking for a more versatile puck and mallet set that comes with a variety of size options, this set by Qtimal delivers. This package includes two puck sizes. The pack of four smaller pucks weighs in at only seven grams and measures in at two and a half inches. The two bigger pucks are twenty grams each and measure in at just under three inches, which makes them quite smaller than the standard sized pucks that you would normally use on a full-sized air hockey table.

The included strikers are just under four inches in diameter and two and a half inches tall. These mallets will work for most standard-sized tables. Their ergonomic design enhances gameplay and promotes longer use.

Both the pucks and paddles are made out of thick, tough ABS plastic, which is designed to resist cracks and chips. The bottom of the paddles are covered in a soft, thin felt, which promotes faster gliding action while protecting your table against scratches and dings.

Additionally, this set also comes with a large drawstring bag, so you can keep all of your air hockey accessories together. It will also come in handy if you need to transport your gear.

Pros

  • Bottoms of mallets are covered in felt
  • Two puck sizes
  • Ergonomic strikers
  • Free drawstring bag
  • Made out of ABS plastic

Cons

  • Smaller pucks are not designed for full-sized tables

Conclusion

A great choice for tables of all sizes, if you’re on a tight budget, this set will give you plenty of bang for your buck. This large set comes with two different sized pucks and two ergonomic mallets. Made out of ABS plastic, the strikers and paddles will not crack or chip during use. The felt covered bottoms of the mallets allow you to quickly and smoothly shoot the pucks across the table while preventing scratches, chips, or dings in the table’s surface. Overall, this set is the total package, so if you’re looking to upgrade your air hockey set, this set is a steal for the price.

Best Value-Billiard Evolution 2 Air Hockey Pushers & 4 Pucks

Billiard evolution set

Our Rating: (4.5/5)

This pusher and puck set by Billiard Evolution comes with four pucks and two strikers. The pushers are just under four inches in diameter and a little over two and a half inches tall. The four pucks come in different colors and shapes. You’ll get one black octagon-shaped puck, one red triangle, one black triangle, and one red round puck, all of which measure in at two and a half inches wide. The different shapes of the pucks will not negatively impact gameplay in terms of gliding ability and speed. However, their unique designs can add a new element of fun to your next match.

The two cream-colored strikers have a thin soft layer of felt on the bottom, which prevents damage to the surface of the table and also promotes faster gliding action. The mallets are made out of ABS plastic and have a hollow design that helps to keep the weight down.

Pros

  • Made out of ABS plastic
  • Strikers feature a hollow, lightweight design
  • Comes with pucks in a variety of shapes and colors
  • Strikers have felt covered bottoms
  • Comes with six pucks and two strikers

Cons

  • The shapes of the pucks can make it difficult to predict ricochet shots

Conclusion

There are pros and cons with every type of striker and puck set you’ll come across, however, some professional players have weighed in and noted that the triangle-shaped pucks can make it more difficult to predict a ricochet shot, which can be a huge drawback for some players. Overall, this is a great set and one that comes with four pucks and a couple of durable, lightweight strikers that can handle everyday use without cracking or chipping. Additionally, the ergonomic strikers promote longer gameplay and allow you to wipe the floor with your opponent in total comfort.

Best Choice for Kid Air Hockey Tables-Vktech 4Pcs Air Hockey Table Goalies and Pucks

Vktech 4pcs set

Our Rating: (4.5/5)

This goalie and puck set consists of four mallets and four pucks. The mallets are ninety-six millimeters in diameter and seventy millimeters tall. The pucks measure in at sixty-three millimeters in diameter and five millimeters tall. The mallets are solidly built, lightweight, and easy to hold. Their size is much smaller than what you would normally use for a full-sized table, however, this smaller design can also make the strikers easier to control.

In terms of durability, I felt that the strikers fell flat. They’re made out of a thin plastic, instead of ABS plastic, which is chip and crack resistant. These mallets are nowhere near as durable and may be prone to damage during rough gameplay. Additionally, the smaller mallet design can be problematic for users with bigger hands. Overall, this set is a great buy since it comes with so many pieces and it has a low price tag, but if you’re searching for tournament-quality strikers, these just aren’t in.

Pros

  • Lightweight mallets
  • Small striker design improves control
  • Perfect for adults and children

Cons

  • Smaller than average pucks and strikers
  • Made out of thin plastic
  • Not recommended for tournament use

Conclusion

This large set is available at an impressively low price. But is it worth it? The mallets are made out of a standard plastic and feature a hollow design that will help to keep the weight down, while the compact build of the strikers is supposed to give the user more control over the pusher, however, this smaller size makes them inappropriate for tournament use and can even make it difficult for users with big hands to hang onto. For the most part, I felt that this set was a better option for the kids. If you’re having a hard time finding a replacement set for your child’s air hockey table, then this set is a great option, but if you’re in need of durable mallets and pucks that can handle gameplay with the big boys, you’ll need to keep looking.

Most Durable-ONE250 Air Hockey Pushers and Red Air Hockey Pucks

One250 set

Our Rating: (4.5/5)

This set by One250 comes with a total of four strikers that are just under four inches wide and a little under two and a half inches tall. Their size makes them suitable for standard and tabletop air hockey tables. Also included are four traditional red pucks that are two and a half inches in diameter.

Both the pucks and the strikers are made out of tough ABS plastic, so you know they’re designed to last and won’t crack like strikers made out of thin plastic tend to do when put to the test. The grip of the strikers is wide enough for adults but not so big that they can’t be comfortably gripped by children.

One major drawback that may be a deal-breaker for some buyers is the lack of felt on the bottom of the strikers. The felt is supposed to work twofold by making it easier for the strikers to move over the surface of the table and it also helps to prevent the mallets from marking up the table’s surface. Of course, the bottom of the strikers are very smooth, but if you’re cautious and want to protect the surface of your table, then you may want to opt for a different set.

Pros

  • Made out of ABS plastic
  • Comfortable grip
  • Perfect for air hockey tables of all sizes

Cons

  • Strikers do not have felt on the bottom

Conclusion

This budget-friendly set comes with plenty of strikers or pucks, so it’s perfect for round tables or multiple player use. The biggest drawback for some is the lack of felt on the bottom of the strikers. But overall, the ABS construction and the comfortable handles are enough to make most shoppers hit that buy now button.

Buyer’s Guide

If you’re an avid air hockey fan and practicing how to prepare for an air hockey tournament, then you already know that mallets and pucks can make a huge difference in how you play the game. Since both strikers and pucks are prone to plenty of wear and tear, they need to be replaced pretty frequently for even, smooth gameplay. The mallets should be light, tough, and comfortable to hold, while the pucks need to be heavy enough to prevent them from flying off the table and have the type of smooth gliding action that allows you to try out the latest air hockey tricks.

Puck Weight

Aside from the size of the table, when you’re upgrading the accessories, you need to consider what size and style of pucks you want to play with. As an example, a tabletop air hockey table will use much smaller pucks than a full-sized table since the table will have a much smaller fan that’s not designed to lift larger pucks. When buying, make sure you pay close attention to puck size and note whether or not the manufacturer lists if the pucks are for smaller or full-sized tables. The wrong size can definitely impact your gameplay.

Dimensions

Small and medium-sized pucks typically measure in at one and a half to two and a half inches in diameter, and can weigh anywhere from ten up to thirty ounces. Larger pucks can weigh over forty ounces and measure in at almost four inches in diameter. These are the pucks you’ll want to use for full-sized arcade-quality tables.

Striker Design

Choosing a new set of strikers can be tricky. For the most part, you’re looking for mallets that are built tough and won’t crack or chip from intense gameplay, but they should also be comfortable to hold and feature the type of lightweight design that lets you smoothly and quickly hit a puck.

Puck Material

Puck Material

Pucks are usually one-inch to one and a half inches thick and are made out of polycarbonate resin. They will have a thin layer of plastic tape on top in order to differentiate the top from the bottom.

Gliding Ability

Have you ever played with stock pucks and strikers? Have you noticed that you have to use more effort to get the puck to move faster or even make it all the way across the table? Are the strikers heavier, bulky, and awkward to hold onto? All of this is pretty typical with stock accessories, which is why most air hockey table owners often upgrade right away.

For both the mallets and pucks, the best way to check out their action is to test them out, but if you’re ordering your new set online, then you’ll have to rely on reviews to learn how smoothly the pucks and strikers move across the table’s surface.

Certification

Some sets will have USAA certification, which means they have been deemed pro-quality and have been given the nod from the United States Air Hockey Association. This can be a great indication of quality, however, don’t be quick to dismiss a set that isn’t USAA certified.

Quality Matters

Cheap, low-quality sets may be available at a lower price, but you’ll really be sacrificing quality just to save a few bucks. Just like most things in life, you really do get what you pay for. If you’re looking for pucks and mallets that offer a nice weight, perfect gliding action, and a smooth design, you can expect to pay more, however, with a higher rated set you’ll immediately notice a huge difference in terms of gliding action and speed, especially if you’ve mainly only played with stock accessories.

Final Thoughts

The whole point of buying the best air hockey pucks and paddles is to make an important upgrade that will improve gameplay, whether it’s faster action that you’re looking for or a smoother glide. These sets that I’ve reviewed each offer the type of quality that most air hockey enthusiasts are looking for. If you’re tired of losing match after match and want to know how to win at air hockey, upgrading your pucks and strikers is a great place to start. In fact, you’ll notice a change in how you play, the pace of the game and a definite improvement in how smooth the action is.